Relationships & Recovery
You Don't Want Them Back. You Still Think About Them Every Day. Both Things Are True.
A clinical psychologist on why the mind keeps returning to someone you have no intention of contacting, what makes it last years, and when it has become something else.
Thinking about an ex constantly is not evidence that you should be with them. The mind returns to unfinished things, not to correct ones. Where a relationship ended without an explanation you could accept, the thinking continues because the question is still open, not because the person was right for you.
"People apologise to me for still thinking about someone they left. They have decided that wanting to understand something is the same as wanting it back. It is not, and confusing the two keeps people stuck for years longer than they need to be."
It has been two years. You would not take their call. You are, on any honest accounting, better off.
And you thought about them this morning, and yesterday, and at some point during the wedding you attended last weekend where somebody played a song.
Here is what is actually happening, and none of it means you made the wrong decision.
Your mind finishes things. This one did not finish
The mind holds incomplete tasks in a way it does not hold completed ones. It is why you remember an unsent email and forget the sent one entirely, and it applies to relationships considerably more forcefully than to correspondence.
A relationship that ended with a reason you could accept tends to close. One that ended in silence, or in an explanation that never quite made sense, or because of family pressure that had nothing to do with the two of you, stays open. Your mind returns to it the way a tongue returns to a broken tooth, not because it enjoys the process, but because something is unresolved and it keeps checking.
This is why people who were left abruptly think about it far longer than people who watched a relationship slowly end. The pain is not necessarily greater. The file is simply still open.
Attachment does not switch off when a decision is made
You decided. Your nervous system did not receive the memo.
Attachment is a physiological system rather than an opinion. It formed over months or years, and it does not dissolve because you concluded the relationship was unwise. This is why people who ended things themselves are frequently more confused than people who were left: they expected their own decision to be honoured by their own body, and it was not.
What you are experiencing is closer to withdrawal than to indecision. The person was, for a period, your primary regulator, the one you told things to first. That role does not vacate itself, and until something else occupies it the mind keeps reaching for the familiar address. How you attach generally makes a substantial difference to how long this lasts.
You are not missing them. You are missing the version of yourself
This is the one people find most useful, and it takes some sitting with.
A great deal of what feels like missing a person is missing who you were with them. The version of you that was chosen, that had somebody to send a photograph to at three in the afternoon, that had a future already sketched out and did not have to think about it.
Losing a relationship costs you a whole imagined life: the flat you had discussed, the way your parents had started referring to them, where you thought you would be at thirty-five. That is a real loss, and it is one people rarely grieve directly because it feels foolish to mourn something that never happened.
The test is simple and mildly uncomfortable. When you picture them now, are you picturing the person, or are you picturing a scene with you in it?
The relationship you are remembering is not the one you had
Memory is not a recording. It is reassembled each time, and it edits in a consistent direction.
What survives is the highlight reel: the good weekend, the way they laughed at something, the early months. What fades is the tedium of the arguments, the specific texture of feeling unheard, the fortnight you barely spoke. This is ordinary memory function rather than a personal failing, and it is why people can miss a relationship that was, by their own contemporaneous account, making them miserable.
Anyone who kept messages from that period and reads them back is usually startled. The relationship in the archive is not the relationship in the memory.
Intermittent contact keeps the wound open
A birthday message once a year. A story view. A like on a photograph after four months of nothing.
Unpredictable reward is the most powerful reinforcement pattern there is, which is why slot machines work and why steady, reliable contact would actually be easier to recover from. Each small signal restarts the process, and the interval between them is what makes it impossible to settle.
People are rarely doing this cruelly. Most are keeping a door slightly open because closing it entirely feels final to them too. The effect on you is the same regardless of the intention.
Their life is now visible in a way no previous generation had to manage
Every previous generation of heartbroken people had the enormous advantage of not knowing what happened next. You know. You know where they went in December and who was standing beside them.
And what you are seeing is a curated feed compared against your unedited interior, which is a comparison nobody survives well. The person appearing content in those photographs may be doing considerably worse than they look. You have no way of knowing, and the comparison runs anyway.
Where this gets specifically difficult in India
The relationship your family never acknowledged
If you were with someone for four years and your parents never knew, or knew and disapproved, then the ending arrives with no condolence attached. Nobody asks how you are. There is no permission to be visibly affected, because officially nothing occurred.
Grief that cannot be expressed does not shrink. It goes underground and lasts considerably longer, which is why people carry these particular endings for years.
The one that ended over caste, community or family refusal
This is the version I see most often, and it is the hardest, because nothing about it resolves. The relationship did not fail. It was not permitted. There is no lesson to extract and no fault to assign, which removes the two things people normally use to close a chapter.
People in this position often describe a permanent low-grade sense that their real life was the one they were not allowed to have.
Marrying someone else while this is still live
Arranged marriages frequently follow closely behind an ended relationship, sometimes within months. That leaves people conducting a new marriage with an unfinished attachment running underneath it, and feeling profoundly guilty about both.
It is more common than anybody admits, it does not mean the marriage is doomed, and it is very difficult to resolve without saying it out loud to somebody.
What the research shows
Sources: published psychological research on recovery timelines following relationship dissolution, including Gilbert and colleagues on affective forecasting after breakups; divorce adjustment literature; India State-Level Disease Burden Initiative, The Lancet Psychiatry. Timelines are averages that vary widely, and Indian data specifically is limited.
Some things need saying out loud to somebody
Sessions with Dr. Kohli directly, in Gurugram or online worldwide, in English or Hindi. Confidential, including from your family.
Book a session WhatsApp +91 9811862338When it has become something other than heartbreak
Most of this is ordinary and passes. Four versions do not, and they are treated differently.
Rumination rather than remembering
Remembering has texture and moves around. Rumination is the same three scenes on a loop, usually the final conversation, replayed for hours with no new conclusion ever reached. If you are conducting the same imaginary argument you were conducting last March, that is a thinking pattern rather than a feeling, and it responds well to treatment.
Compulsive checking
Looking at their profile several times daily, keeping an account to see what you were blocked from, monitoring a mutual friend for information. Where relief is brief and the checking expands, it is running on the same machinery as any other reassurance-seeking loop, and treating it as a discipline problem does not work.
Limerence
An intense, intrusive preoccupation that can attach to someone you barely knew, or to a relationship that lasted six weeks. It has more in common with an obsessional state than with love, it is startlingly common, and people rarely have a name for it, which makes it more distressing than it needs to be.
Depression underneath
Where sleep, appetite, work and interest have all gone, and the thinking about them is the most articulate symptom rather than the cause. This is common after an ending and it is worth assessing properly rather than waiting out, since it does not reliably lift on its own.
Three years, and a question nobody had answered
A man in his early thirties came to me about work stress. Somewhere in the third session he mentioned a relationship that had ended three years earlier when her family refused the match.
He was married by then, reasonably happily. He did not want her back and said so with obvious sincerity. He also thought about her most days and had never told a single person, including his wife, including his closest friend.
What kept it alive was not longing. It was that nobody had ever explained it to him. Her family had said no, she had stopped replying, and that was the entire account he had been given of the end of four years.
The work was not about her. It was about giving him somewhere to say it out loud, and helping him accept an ending that had never been narrated. It took about six sessions.
A composite drawn from several presentations, not a real client. No identifying details belong to any individual.
What actually helps
- Write the account nobody gave you. What happened, in order, including the parts that reflect badly on you. Endings that were never narrated stay open, and narrating them yourself works considerably better than people expect.
- Read back what you wrote at the time. Messages, a journal, anything from the last six months of the relationship. The archive corrects the highlight reel, and nothing else does it as efficiently.
- Close the intermittent contact properly. Not as a punishment. Because unpredictable signals are the single thing most reliably preventing this from settling.
- Grieve the imagined life separately. The flat, the plan, where you thought you would be at thirty-five. That is a real loss and it needs mourning in its own right rather than being folded into missing a person.
- Tell one person the whole of it. Particularly if your family never knew. Grief that has never been spoken aloud does not fade, it simply goes quiet, and it can stay that way for a decade.
If an ending has brought thoughts of not wanting to be here, please tell someone today rather than waiting for it to pass. If you cannot keep yourself safe, contact your local emergency services or attend your nearest hospital now.
Six sessions is often enough for this
Thirty years of clinical practice, in Gurugram and online worldwide. In English or Hindi, and nobody needs to know you came.
Book a session WhatsApp +91 9811862338Related reading
If something on this page landed, these go further.
- Attachment styles. Why some people take far longer to let go.
- Depression. When an ending has become something more.
- Anxiety. Rumination, and how it is actually treated.
- OCD and intrusive thoughts. When the checking has taken over.
- Grief counselling. Loss without a death is still loss.
- Premarital counselling. Marrying with something unfinished behind you.
- Marriage counselling. When it is affecting the marriage you are in.
Common questions
Why can't I stop thinking about my ex when I don't want them back?
Because the mind returns to unfinished things rather than to correct ones. If the relationship ended without an explanation you could accept, the question stays open and your mind keeps checking it. Wanting to understand something is not the same as wanting it back, and confusing the two keeps people stuck for years longer than necessary.
How long should this take?
Research on non-marital breakups suggests most people notice a clear shift within about three months, while divorce recovery is typically much longer. Those are averages with enormous variation. What is more informative than elapsed time is direction: whether it occupies less of your day than it did six months ago.
Is it normal to miss someone I chose to leave?
Extremely. Attachment is a physiological system rather than an opinion, and it does not dissolve because you reached a conclusion. People who ended things themselves are often more confused than those who were left, because they expected their own decision to be honoured by their own body.
Why do I only remember the good parts?
Memory is reassembled rather than replayed, and it edits consistently toward the highlights. The arguments lose their texture; the good weekend keeps its detail. Reading back messages from the last months of the relationship is the fastest correction available, and most people are startled by the gap.
Does no contact actually work?
Yes, and not for the reason usually given. It is not a strategy to make them return. Intermittent, unpredictable contact is the most powerful reinforcement pattern there is, so occasional messages or story views restart the process each time. Steady silence is genuinely easier to recover from than sporadic warmth.
Should I unfollow them on social media?
It helps considerably more than people expect. Every previous generation recovered without knowing what happened next, which was an advantage. You are also comparing a curated feed against your own unedited interior, and that comparison has no good outcome regardless of how either of you is actually doing.
My relationship ended because of family or caste. Why is this so much harder?
Because nothing about it resolves. The relationship did not fail, it was not permitted, so there is no lesson to take and no fault to assign, and those are the two things people normally use to close a chapter. Grief that was also never acknowledged by anyone around you lasts considerably longer for that reason alone.
I'm married and still thinking about someone from before. What does that mean?
Usually that an attachment was never finished rather than that the marriage is wrong. It is far more common than anybody admits, particularly where a marriage followed closely behind an ended relationship. It is also very difficult to resolve privately, because the one thing that helps most is saying it aloud to somebody outside it.
When is this something more than heartbreak?
When it has become rumination rather than remembering, meaning the same few scenes on a loop with no new conclusion. When checking their profile brings brief relief and then expands. When sleep, appetite and interest have all gone. Each of those is treated differently, and each responds well to the right approach.
What is limerence?
An intense, intrusive preoccupation with someone that can attach to a person you barely knew or a relationship that lasted weeks. It has more in common with an obsessional state than with love. It is common, most people have no name for it, and having one usually reduces the distress considerably.
Is it disloyal to talk about an ex in therapy while I'm married?
No, and it is one of the most common things people apologise for before saying. An unfinished attachment running underneath a marriage affects the marriage, so addressing it is generally the more loyal act. Sessions are confidential, including from your spouse and your family.
How many sessions does this usually take?
Often fewer than people fear. Where the difficulty is an ending that was never explained or never spoken about, a handful of sessions is frequently enough, because the work is narrating something rather than dismantling something. Where depression or long-standing rumination sits underneath, it takes longer.
This page is general psychoeducation and not a substitute for individual assessment or treatment. If you are in immediate danger or unable to keep yourself safe, contact your local emergency services or attend your nearest hospital without delay.